A pre-retrofit EnerGuide evaluation of a 2008 two storey home in West Kelowna Estates found the hot and cold rooms came from the stack effect, a ducted system that struggled upstairs, bare crawlspace walls and a leaky garage-to-crawlspace door. The house rates 142 GJ/year, about 20 percent more energy than a typical new house of the same size.
The upgrade roadmap models a path to 19 GJ/year with all upgrades, led by a dual fuel heat pump (57 GJ/year on its own), with estimated energy costs dropping from about $2,890 to about $590 a year. These are modelled numbers, not measured savings.
Evaluation and report by Noah Salisbury, Registered Energy Advisor, Thrive Energy Inc., July 2026.
Project at a glance
| Project detail | Description |
|---|---|
| Location | West Kelowna Estates, West Kelowna, BC |
| Project type | Two storey single family home built in 2008, about 3,200 sq ft, on a crawlspace |
| Service | Pre-retrofit EnerGuide evaluation with blower door test |
| Evaluation date | July 2026 |
| Current EnerGuide rating | 142 GJ/year, about 20 percent more energy than a typical new house of the same size |
| Potential rating with all upgrades | 19 GJ/year (modelled) |
The problem: rooms that were too hot or too cold
The homeowners had rooms that were too hot or too cold, and low airflow at some of the registers. They wanted to know more about how the house was performing and which improvements would make the biggest difference.
What the EnerGuide evaluation involved
Noah did a full EnerGuide evaluation. That means a blower door test for airtightness, measuring and recording the insulation, windows, doors and mechanical equipment, and building an energy model of the house in HOT2000, the software Natural Resources Canada uses for the EnerGuide Rating System. The model shows where the house loses heat and what each upgrade would do.
What the evaluation found
The house is heated with a 92 percent efficient gas furnace, cooled with a 13 SEER central air conditioner, and has an electric tank water heater with an energy factor of 0.90. The blower door test came in at 3.42 air changes per hour at 50 Pascals.
| Area | Share of heat loss |
|---|---|
| Windows | 26% |
| Main walls | 24% |
| Foundation and crawlspace | 23% |
| Air leakage and ventilation | 18% |
| Attic | 6% |
| Exposed floors and doors | 3% |
A few things stood out:
- Upstairs comfort. The ducted system was struggling to keep the upper floor comfortable, which lines up with the hot and cold rooms the homeowners described.
- Bare crawlspace walls. Part of the crawlspace had bare concrete walls with no insulation.
- The garage crawl door. The access door from the garage into the crawlspace was a major source of air leakage from the garage into the house.
- Smaller leaks. Interior window seams, electrical outlets, a cat door and some older door weatherstripping. The attic hatch was already sealed.
Why the upstairs is harder to keep comfortable
Part of it is the stack effect. Warm air rises, so in a two storey house the upper floor collects heat and pushes air out through leaks near the top of the house, while the lower floor pulls outside air in through leaks down low, like the crawlspace and the garage crawl door. In summer, the upstairs also picks up heat through the attic and from sun on the windows. One ducted system on one thermostat can’t make up for that difference between floors, so upstairs bedrooms tend to run hot in summer while the main floor can feel cool and drafty in winter. That’s why Thrive suggested mini-splits upstairs, so the upper floor can be heated and cooled on its own.
The upgrade roadmap
The upgrade report lays the work out as a roadmap, so the homeowners can decide what to do now and what to plan for over the next few years. Each modelled saving below is for that upgrade on its own.
| Upgrade | Modelled saving |
|---|---|
| Dual fuel heat pump paired with a high efficiency gas furnace | 57 GJ/year |
| Insulate the bare crawlspace walls (about R-12 added) | 15 GJ/year |
| Heat pump water heater | 11 GJ/year |
| Add attic insulation (R-38 up to about R-60) | 3 GJ/year |
| Air sealing, including the garage crawl door and cat door | 2 GJ/year |
| Solar PV, about 12 kW | 50 GJ/year |
For the comfort problem, Thrive also suggested ductless mini-splits upstairs where the ducted system struggles to keep up, and an HRV to bring in filtered fresh air as the house gets tighter. Air sealing is only recommended after a radon test, since sealing a house can raise radon levels.
The heat pump is the biggest single item because space heating is 62 percent of this home’s energy use. A dual fuel system lets the heat pump handle most of the heating season at two to three times the efficiency of gas, with the furnace taking over on the coldest days. It also replaces the old air conditioner.
Modelled results with all upgrades
Estimated energy costs could drop from about $2,890 a year to about $590 with all upgrades, including solar.
These are modelled numbers based on standard operating conditions and current BC Hydro and FortisBC rates, not measured savings. With every upgrade done, the EnerGuide rating would go from 142 to 19 GJ/year and greenhouse gas emissions from 4.9 to 0.5 tonnes a year. When the homeowners finish their upgrades, a post-retrofit evaluation will show what was actually achieved.
What other homeowners can take from this
- Hot and cold rooms usually have a cause. An evaluation shows whether it’s the envelope, the ductwork, the equipment or a mix, so you aren’t guessing.
- Do the envelope before the equipment. Air sealing and insulation first can mean a smaller, cheaper heat pump. A proper heat load calculation should be done before sizing new equipment.
- Check the crawlspace and garage. Uninsulated crawlspace walls and an unsealed door from the garage are easy to miss and can make a real difference.
- Get the evaluation before you start. Some rebate bonuses need a pre-upgrade EnerGuide evaluation and a post-upgrade one too. Rebates change, so confirm the requirements before work begins.
Frequently asked questions
Why is the upstairs of a two storey house hotter than the main floor?
Part of it is the stack effect. Warm air rises, so the upper floor collects heat and pushes air out through leaks near the top of the house, while the lower floor pulls outside air in through leaks down low. In summer, the upstairs also picks up heat through the attic and from sun on the windows, and one ducted system on one thermostat can’t make up for that difference between floors.
Where was this West Kelowna Estates home losing the most heat?
Windows were 26 percent of the heat loss, main walls 24 percent, the foundation and crawlspace 23 percent, air leakage and ventilation 18 percent, the attic 6 percent, and exposed floors and doors 3 percent.
Which upgrade had the biggest modelled saving?
A dual fuel heat pump paired with a high efficiency gas furnace, at 57 GJ/year on its own, because space heating is 62 percent of this home’s energy use. Solar PV of about 12 kW was next at 50 GJ/year.
How much could the homeowners save on energy costs?
Estimated energy costs could drop from about $2,890 a year to about $590 with all upgrades, including solar. These are modelled numbers based on standard operating conditions and current BC Hydro and FortisBC rates, not measured savings.
Book an EnerGuide home evaluation
If you have rooms that never feel right, an EnerGuide evaluation shows where your home loses heat and which upgrades will make the biggest difference.
Call 778-867-0242 or contact Thrive Energy.