Thrive Energy modelled a new Part 9 rental building in Penticton for CMHC MLI Select. The proposed building models 61 percent lower energy use and 98.7 percent lower greenhouse gas emissions than the National Building Code reference building, well past the 40 percent the energy efficiency points required.
The result came from envelope upgrades, a 1.5 ACH50 airtightness target, a cold climate heat pump, a heat pump water heater and an HRV, with emissions recalculated using BC’s own emission factors.
Energy modelling and report by Brett Tracy, Registered Energy Advisor, Thrive Energy Inc.
Project at a glance
| Project detail | Description |
|---|---|
| Location | Penticton, BC |
| Project type | New construction multi-unit residential rental building, Part 9 |
| Service | HOT2000 energy modelling, CMHC MLI Select upgrade report and BC Energy Step Code compliance |
| Target | At least 40 percent better than the National Building Code reference building on energy and greenhouse gas emissions |
| Result (modelled) | 61 percent less energy use and 98.7 percent lower emissions than the reference |
The project: financing a rental building through MLI Select
The owner was financing a new rental building through CMHC MLI Select, a mortgage loan insurance program that gives better financing terms to rental projects that score points for affordability, accessibility and energy efficiency. To earn the energy efficiency points, the building had to be modelled at least 40 percent better than a code-minimum reference building, with a report CMHC could rely on for the funding decision.
How the energy modelling was done
Thrive built energy models of the proposed building in HOT2000, along with matching National Building Code reference models, so CMHC could compare the two directly. The proposed model uses the assembly and mechanical selections planned for the building, so the report shows exactly what has to be built to hit the target.
Two things are worth knowing about how these reports work:
- The comparison is against a code-minimum building, not the owner’s first design. The reference model uses code-minimum walls, windows and airtightness, with electric baseboard heat and a standard electric water heater.
- Greenhouse gas emissions are calculated with BC’s emission factors. HOT2000 uses a national factor that overstates emissions for BC’s mostly hydro-powered grid. Thrive recalculated emissions using the provincial factors from Canada’s National Inventory Report, which is what CMHC needs to see.
The selections that got it there
| Item | Code reference building | Proposed building |
|---|---|---|
| Main walls | R-17.5 effective | R-31 nominal (2×6 with R-24 batts plus 2 inches of exterior EPS) |
| Attic | R-49.5 effective | R-51 nominal |
| Slab edge | No insulation | R-16 |
| Windows | U-1.85 | U-1.40, SHGC 0.30 |
| Airtightness target | 3.0 ACH50 | 1.5 ACH50 |
| Heating and cooling | Electric baseboards and central A/C | Cold climate air source heat pump, centrally ducted |
| Hot water | Standard electric tank | Heat pump water heater (COP 4.31) |
| Ventilation | None modelled | HRV at 75 percent sensible recovery |
Modelled results against the code reference
| Result | Code reference | Proposed | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Energy use | 154 GJ/year | 59.6 GJ/year | 61% lower |
| Greenhouse gas emissions | 61.6 t/year | 0.8 t/year | 98.7% lower |
| Design heat loss | 185.9 GJ | 116.9 GJ | 37% lower |
That clears the 40 percent requirement by a wide margin. The lower design heat loss can also mean smaller heating equipment, which helps offset some of the cost of the envelope upgrades. The report went to CMHC with the energy matrix, the full HOT2000 reports for both models and the signed energy efficiency attestation.
What other builders and owners can take from this
- Bring in the energy advisor at design stage. It’s much cheaper to change a wall assembly or a window spec on paper than after framing starts.
- The envelope and the heat pump work together. Better walls, windows and airtightness cut the heat loss, so a smaller heat pump can do the job.
- Make sure emissions are calculated with BC numbers. On an all-electric building in BC, using provincial emission factors makes a big difference to the result.
- One model can cover more than one program. The same HOT2000 work supported both the MLI Select report and the BC Energy Step Code compliance reports for the permit.
Frequently asked questions
How much better than code does a building need to model for MLI Select energy efficiency points?
For this project, the building had to be modelled at least 40 percent better than a code-minimum reference building on energy and greenhouse gas emissions. The proposed building modelled 61 percent lower energy use and 98.7 percent lower emissions.
What is the MLI Select reference building compared against?
The comparison is against a code-minimum building, not the owner’s first design. The reference model uses code-minimum walls, windows and airtightness, with electric baseboard heat and a standard electric water heater.
Why recalculate emissions with BC emission factors?
HOT2000 uses a national factor that overstates emissions for BC’s mostly hydro-powered grid. Thrive recalculated emissions using the provincial factors from Canada’s National Inventory Report, which is what CMHC needs to see.
Can the same energy model be used for MLI Select and the BC Energy Step Code?
Yes. On this project, the same HOT2000 work supported both the MLI Select report and the BC Energy Step Code compliance reports for the permit.
Talk to Thrive about MLI Select energy modelling
If you’re planning a rental project and looking at MLI Select, bring Thrive in at design stage to model the building before the specs are locked.
Call 778-867-0242 or contact Thrive Energy.